| Paul Douglas | Man on Park Bench (uncredited) |
| Jimmie Dundee | Pencil Louie's Driver (uncredited) |
| Al Ferguson | Policeman in Garden (uncredited) |
| James Flavin | O'Leary, Manhattan Police Chief (uncredited) |
| Adda Gleason | Maid (uncredited) |
| Sandra Gould | Housewife Bettor (uncredited) |
| Joe Gray | Baseball Player (uncredited) |
| Mack Gray | Suspect in Polo Coat in Line-Up (uncredited) |
| Don Haggerty | Policeman (uncredited) |
| Chuck Hamilton | Detective (uncredited) |
| Stuart Holmes | Golfer (uncredited) |
| Wilbur Mack | Golfer (uncredited) |
| George Magrill | Policeman at Ballpark (uncredited) |
| Strother Martin | Michael 'Shorty' McGirk (uncredited) |
| Edwin Max | Fish Eye (uncredited) |
| Howard Negley | Process Server (uncredited) |
| Leonard Nimoy | Young Baseball Player (uncredited) |
| Jack Perry | Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited) |
| Joe Ploski | Henchman (uncredited) |
| Ralph Sanford | Eddie - Brooklyn Police Chief (uncredited) |
| Charles Sherlock | Court Clerk (uncredited) |
| Bert Stevens | Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited) |
| Jack Stoney | Henchman (uncredited) |
| Frank Sully | Big Head Charlie - Bookie (uncredited) |
| Dorothy Vernon | Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited) |
| Sailor Vincent | Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited) |
| Ben Welden | Oily Moe - Bookie (uncredited) |
| Sedal Bennett | |
| Herman Boden | Photographer (uncredited) |
| John Breen | Western Union Boy (uncredited) |
| Ralph Brooks | Dill's Lawyer #2 (uncredited) |
| Joseph Bryan | Radio Announcer (uncredited) |
| Charles Campbell | Announcer (uncredited) |
| Douglas Carter | Newspaper Reporter (uncredited) |
| James Conaty | Sporting Goods Store Customer (uncredited) |
| Jack Daly | Officer (uncredited) |
| Mike Donovan | Bartender (uncredited) |
| Charles Ferguson | Baseball Player (uncredited) |
| Frank Fiumara | Baseball Player (uncredited) |
| Howard Gardiner | Bailiff (uncredited) |
| Roy Gordon | Golfer (uncredited) |
| Tom Hanlon | Radio Announcer (voice) (uncredited) |
| Buck Harrington | Proprietor (uncredited) |
| Hans Herbert | Doctor (uncredited) |
| F. Herrick Herrick | Newspaper Reporter (uncredited) |
| Wally Hood | Umpire (uncredited) |
| Jerry James | Policeman (uncredited) |
| Curtis Jarrett | |
| Dolly Jarvis | Photographer (uncredited) |
| Richard Karlan | Pencil Louie (uncredited) |
| Harold J. Kennedy | Sporting Goods Salesman (uncredited) |
| Donald Kerr | Taxi Driver (uncredited) |
| Michele Lange | Newspaper Reporter (uncredited) |
| Grace Lenard | Kitty (uncredited) |
| Arthur Lovejoy | Minister (uncredited) |
| Paul Maxey | Mr. Reese - Board Member (uncredited) |
| Stanley McKay | Newspaper Reporter (uncredited) |
| William Meader | Photographer (uncredited) |
| Lee Miller | Baseball Player (uncredited) |
| Rex Moore | Caddy (uncredited) |
| Will Orlean | Hoodlum (uncredited) |
| Stanley Orr | Newspaper Reporter (uncredited) |
| Ruth Packard | Minister's Wife (uncredited) |
| Sam Pierce | Barber (uncredited) |
| Hilda Plowright | Katie (uncredited) |
| Anthony Radecki | Baseball Player (uncredited) |
| Roberta Richards | Reporter (uncredited) |
| Carl Saxe | St. Louis Baseball Player (uncredited) |
| Frank J. Scannell | Hamburger Harry - Bookie (uncredited) |
| George Sherwood | Mr. Thompson (uncredited) |
| Charles Sullivan | Fan With Binoculars (uncredited) |
| Gus Taillon | Sexton (uncredited) |
| Joseph Terry | Caddy (uncredited) |
| William Thourlby | Baseball Player (uncredited) |
| Harry Varteresian | Elbert (uncredited) |
| Billy Wayne | St. Louis Manager (uncredited) |
| Eric Wilton | Golfer (uncredited) |
| Hank Wise | Baseball Pitcher (uncredited) |
| Douglas Wood | Mr. Carroll - Board Member (uncredited) |
| Orangey | Rhubarb |
